6 Game-Changing Etsy Secrets You Need to Know

If you’re hungry for success on Etsy and wondering what the magic formula is, you’re in the right place. As a 7-figure Etsy seller with a background in corporate e-commerce and a team of 25, I’m here to share three of the best-kept secrets that nobody talks about. Buckle up; we’re about to level up your Etsy game!

1. Choose Ground Shipping as Your Default

One of the often-overlooked aspects of Etsy success is in the details of your shipping strategy. My first secret is a game-changer – set Ground Shipping as your default option. Why? It’s not just about being cost-effective; it’s about smart upselling. When you make Ground Shipping the default (which is often the cheapest), customers are prompted to consider faster options, like Priority, for an extra cost. This simple tweak can earn you an additional $10 on each sale. Don’t forget to explore “advanced shipping options” when setting up your shipping methods to enable this feature.

2. Pinterest Strategy: Ditch Idea Pins for Efficiency

If you’ve been spending endless hours on Pinterest creating Idea Pins, it’s time for a shift in strategy. My second secret is all about saving time and optimizing your Pinterest presence. Use the Google Chrome extension to streamline your pinning process. But, a word of caution – Pinterest won’t do wonders for you if your listings aren’t Pinterest-optimized. I’ve personally leveraged Pinterest to drive over 100,000 visits to one of my listings. Let me show you how.

3. Variety is the Spice of Etsy Shops: Digital, POD, and Physical Together

Here’s a revelation: you don’t need separate Etsy shops for digital, print-on-demand (POD), and physical products. My third secret is all about diversity in your shop. Having a range of product types is not only possible but encouraged. The key is to serve a similar customer base without conflicting interests. Think about it – why complicate your life managing multiple shops when you can streamline it all in one?

4. Shop Restart: A Strategic Move for Slow Starters

It’s time to face the reality – if you’ve been swimming upstream for three months with zero sales or six months with less than 10 sales, it might be time for a shop restart. Sometimes, a fresh start can do wonders. Instead of struggling with an uphill battle, strategically reassess, and relaunch with newfound knowledge and experience.

5. Money-Saving Inventory Hacks

Let’s talk dollars and cents. My fifth secret revolves around saving money on inventory. Purchase gift cards from raise.com for your material suppliers, then leverage a reseller’s permit or tap into military/teacher discounts. Imagine combining regular sales with discounts and an additional 30% off through discounted gift cards – that’s a triple win.

6. Embrace Aesthetic Over Niche

The sixth and final secret challenges the conventional advice to pick a niche. Instead, build your shop around a customer-appreciated aesthetic. Forget being pigeonholed into a narrow niche; focus on creating a shop that appeals to customers with a shared vibe. Aesthetics evolve, and you’re better off aligning your brand with customers who appreciate a certain style. Take inspiration from smaller boutiques, like Pigment, that serve diverse customers united by a shared aesthetic.

Wrapping Up

Etsy success is a journey of continuous learning and adapting. By implementing these lesser-known secrets, you’re not just playing the game; you’re mastering it. Remember, success on Etsy is a compilation of many small-to-medium things, and prioritizing them strategically is the key. Here’s to unlocking new levels of success on Etsy!

---

Frequently Asked Questions

How frequently should I reassess my Etsy shop strategy?
Regularly reassess your strategy, especially if you experience a plateau in sales or notice shifts in market trends. Stay adaptable.

Is it advisable to combine digital, POD, and physical products in one shop?
Absolutely! Having a variety of products in one shop is encouraged, provided they cater to a similar customer base.

What should I focus on when building an aesthetic for my shop?
Look beyond Etsy for aesthetic inspiration. Focus on colors, fonts, and vibes that resonate with your target customers. Adapt and evolve your aesthetic as your shop grows.