10 Big Changes to Fix Your Print-on-Demand Etsy Shop

Running a successful print-on-demand Etsy shop can be challenging, but with the right strategy, you can transform your store and start generating consistent sales. In this post, we’ll walk you through 10 essential changes you can make to improve your shop and set it up for long-term growth. These tips come directly from Dylan Jahraus, an experienced Etsy seller with over $1.5 million in revenue. By applying these proven business principles, you can position your Etsy shop for success.

1. Print on Demand Etsy Shop Cohesive Aesthetic and Customer Focus

One of the biggest challenges many print-on-demand Etsy shops face is a lack of cohesive branding. A shop without a unified look and feel can confuse potential customers and make it hard for them to connect with your brand. Dylan emphasizes the importance of creating a consistent aesthetic across your listings, making it easier for customers to recognize your brand and build trust.

Actionable Tip: Identify your target audience and tailor your product designs and branding to appeal to them specifically. Whether you’re targeting millennials with trendy designs or focusing on personalized gifts, your shop’s aesthetic should be cohesive and relevant to your ideal customer.

2. Effective Mockups and Visibility for Print on Demand Etsy Shops

Your product photos are one of the first things potential customers see, so making sure they are clear, eye-catching, and optimized for both desktop and mobile devices is crucial. Many print-on-demand Etsy shops use product mockups with small, hard-to-read text, which can make it difficult for customers to understand the product’s value.

Actionable Tip: Use a mix of high-quality AI-generated mockups and real-life photos to showcase your products. Make sure that text and design elements are clearly visible on mobile devices. An optimized visual experience can dramatically improve engagement and conversions.

3. Optimized SEO and Listing Structure

Even if your products are fantastic, they won’t sell if customers can’t find them. SEO plays a crucial role in how your print-on-demand Etsy shop performs in search results. Poorly optimized titles, descriptions, and tags can hinder your visibility.

Actionable Tip: Implement an effective SEO strategy by researching keywords that your potential customers are searching for. Use tools like eRank or Marmalead to find high-traffic, low-competition keywords and incorporate them naturally into your titles, descriptions, and tags. Ensure that your listings are well-organized with clear sections and categories.

4. Diversified Product Offerings

If your shop focuses exclusively on t-shirts or a limited product range, it can be difficult to increase your average order value (AOV). Offering a wider variety of products that complement your current offerings can help you attract more customers and encourage larger purchases.

Actionable Tip: Diversify your product line by adding new items such as mugs, phone cases, tote bags, or home decor. Consider introducing loss leaders—low-priced items that draw customers in—and upsell more expensive items to increase your AOV.

5. Branding and Trust-Building for Print on Demand Etsy Shops

Trust is a major factor in whether or not a customer will make a purchase. A weak brand identity or lack of trust-building elements (such as reviews or clear policies) can deter potential buyers from shopping with you.

Actionable Tip: Strengthen your branding by including personal elements such as a shop owner photo, a clear “About Us” section, and detailed shop policies. Highlight your return policies, shipping information, and any guarantees you offer. Providing transparency and building trust can significantly increase your conversion rates.

6. Etsy Print on Demand Pricing Strategies

If your print-on-demand Etsy shop is relatively new or has a limited sales history, you may need to adjust your pricing strategy to remain competitive. Some sellers price their products too high too early, which can scare away potential customers.

Actionable Tip: Consider implementing a more aggressive pricing strategy in the early stages of your shop to build up a customer base and generate reviews. Once you’ve established credibility and traction, you can gradually increase your prices to match the value of your products.

7. Intentional Product Curation

A common issue for many Etsy sellers is offering too many products without a clear focus. A cluttered shop with an overwhelming number of items can confuse customers and dilute your brand identity.

Actionable Tip: Trim down your product selection by focusing on your best-sellers and products that align with your target audience. A more curated shop allows you to create a stronger, more recognizable brand and gives you the opportunity to market your products more effectively.

8. Leveraging Customer Reviews

Social proof is incredibly important for building trust and credibility, especially for new print-on-demand Etsy shops. Positive customer reviews provide validation that your products are worth purchasing.

Actionable Tip: Encourage your customers to leave reviews by offering excellent customer service, including thank-you notes or discount codes for future purchases. Once you’ve received positive feedback, showcase these reviews in your product listings to build social proof and increase conversions.

9. Personalized Mockups and Targeting

Another way to improve your print-on-demand shop is by tailoring your mockups and product offerings to specific customer segments. For example, if you sell mugs, consider creating mockups that clearly differentiate between gifts for men and women, or specific occasions like birthdays, holidays, or anniversaries.

Actionable Tip: Personalization is key to making your products stand out in a crowded market. Create product mockups that reflect the intended recipient’s personality or style. This helps potential customers visualize the product as a gift, making them more likely to purchase.

10. Willingness to Start Fresh

Sometimes, it’s best to start over. If your current print-on-demand Etsy shop is missing too many critical elements for long-term success, it may be time to consider starting a new shop with a fresh focus and a more cohesive strategy.

Actionable Tip: If your shop is struggling and you’re finding it difficult to implement these changes, don’t be afraid to start fresh. A new shop with a clearer brand identity, better products, and optimized listings can lead to quicker growth and more sustainable success.

---

By addressing these 10 key areas, you can significantly improve your print-on-demand Etsy shop and position yourself for long-term growth. From refining your brand’s aesthetic to optimizing your SEO and diversifying your product line, these strategies will help you scale your business and drive more sales. If you’re ready to take your shop to the next level, start making these changes today.

FAQ Section

1. How important is SEO for my print-on-demand Etsy shop?

SEO is essential for your print-on-demand Etsy shop because it determines how easily customers can find your products in search results. By optimizing your titles, descriptions, and tags with relevant keywords, you increase your chances of ranking higher and attracting more organic traffic.

2. Should I diversify my product offerings, or stick to one type of product?

Diversifying your product offerings can help you attract a wider range of customers and increase your average order value. Consider adding complementary items to your current selection, such as mugs, phone cases, or tote bags, to appeal to different customer needs and preferences.

3. How can I use customer reviews to boost sales?

Customer reviews are a powerful form of social proof. By showcasing positive reviews in your product listings, you can build trust and credibility with potential buyers, which increases the likelihood of making a sale. Encouraging customers to leave reviews can also help boost your shop’s overall reputation.

Ready to learn more about growing an Etsy shop?

Book a call with us to discuss your Etsy shop, any struggles, and hear more about how we can help you through my program, Multi-Six Figure Etsy Blueprint and 1:1 coaching! https://calendly.com/dylanjahraus/program-strategy-call?month=2024-07

View our student Results: https://dylanjahraus.com/reviews