How to Transform Your Etsy Shop into a Thriving Business

Starting a small business can often feel overwhelming, especially on platforms like Etsy. With an ever-growing number of small businesses hoping to turn their passion projects into profit, there’s a desire for guidance on how to make their shops stand out. 

In a recent conversation on The Lifelong Learners Collective, Etsy coach and entrepreneur Dylan Jahraus shared her experience building a thriving Etsy business from a single listing to a six-figure income. Here are some key takeaways and strategies from Dylan’s journey that may help you take your Etsy shop to the next level.

Prefer to listen instead of read? Listen on Apple Podcasts or Spotify. 

Treat Your Etsy Shop Like a Real Business

In the beginning, Dylan approached her Etsy shop casually, similar to Craigslist or a community bulletin board, with minimal details and a basic listing photo. However, after that first sale, she saw the potential and began applying her corporate e-commerce strategies to her Etsy shop. Her advice? Don’t treat your shop like a hobby—make it a business. This means paying attention to things like SEO, attractive images, detailed descriptions, and consistent branding.

Leverage Your Unique Expertise

Dylan leveraged her background in corporate e-commerce and used strategies she learned while working at Zappos and Zulily. When she applied those insights to her Etsy business, her shop revenue skyrocketed to $10,000 per month in just four months. The message here is to use any relevant skills or experience you have. Maybe you’re skilled at social media marketing or have an eye for design—whatever your strengths, find ways to integrate them into your business to set yourself apart.

Focus on High-Quality, Niche Products

One of the biggest factors in Dylan’s success was understanding her niche and meeting her customers’ needs. She advises Etsy sellers to think less about what they like personally and more about what the customers need or desire. She expanded her product range based on her target customer’s lifestyle and interests, creating a collection of products that appealed to multiple aspects of her audience’s lives. Remember, the goal is to offer value and solutions for your customer’s needs, which will keep them coming back.

Adapt and Grow with Your Business

Dylan emphasizes that building a successful business is a continuous learning process. Even after achieving success on Etsy, she kept evolving, branching out to Shopify and Amazon. She also built a coaching business to help others find similar success. Recognizing growth opportunities, like expanding onto other platforms or adding new services, can help you stay relevant in a changing market. Start with one platform or business model that works for you, but be open to scaling and adapting as your business grows.

Invest in Yourself and Your Time

When her Etsy business became profitable, Dylan focused on outsourcing lower-level tasks, allowing her to dedicate more time to high-impact activities. She hired a team of 31 people for her coaching business and created a sustainable work-life balance. Outsourcing might seem like an expense at first, but buying back your time can be a smart investment that helps you grow your business and avoid burnout.

Ignore the Naysayers and Embrace Social Media

One of the hardest parts of becoming a public figure and sharing content online is dealing with judgment and negativity. Dylan shares that while it can be difficult, focusing on your goals and tuning out negativity is essential. For those thinking about sharing their journey online, her advice is to go for it and not worry about judgment from others.

Final Thoughts

Dylan’s journey demonstrates that growing a successful business takes effort, but with the right mindset, tools, and strategies, it is possible. From making your first sale to hitting six figures, her journey offers inspiration and practical insights for Etsy sellers hoping to turn their creative passions into profitable businesses. So take that leap, embrace the process, and don’t be afraid to invest in yourself—success could be just around the corner.