What to Sell on Etsy: How I Sold Over $500,000 of ONE ITEM

If you’re trying to figure out what to sell on Etsy to achieve massive sales, you’re in the right place. Many Etsy sellers struggle because they offer too many different products, trying to appeal to everyone. This “throw everything at the wall and see what sticks” approach can leave your efforts diluted and your sales stagnant.

In my years of selling on Etsy, I’ve learned that the most effective way to scale your business is by focusing on one key product and becoming the market leader in that niche. In this post, I’ll show you exactly what to sell on Etsy if you want to hit $500,000 in sales, along with tips on how to optimize your listings, dominate a market, and drive consistent organic traffic.

Step 1: Choose a Winning Product to Sell on Etsy

The first step in deciding what to sell on Etsy is choosing a product that can be customized and appeals to a broad audience. Many sellers spread themselves too thin by offering a wide range of products with little connection to each other. This approach prevents them from becoming a true market leader in any one category.

Instead, focus on one product that you can refine and scale. Ask yourself:

• Is this product customizable?
• Does it appeal to a broad but specific audience?
• Can I target different customer types with this one product?

By narrowing down your focus, you give yourself the chance to perfect one product and build authority in that niche. This was the strategy I used to sell over $500,000 of one item on Etsy. I focused all my efforts on that product, optimizing my listings and creating variations to appeal to different customers.

Step 2: Own Your Market

When you’re determining what to sell on Etsy, aim to be the market leader in your chosen product category. Becoming the top seller for one item not only simplifies your shop management but also allows you to charge premium prices. As the market leader, you’ll spend less time updating your listings and more time fulfilling orders and engaging with customers.

In the first year of selling on Etsy, focus on finding opportunities where you can become the go-to shop for that product. Look for areas where competition may not be too fierce and where you can position yourself as an expert. Being the market leader also means you can raise your prices over time as customers start to associate your shop with quality and reliability.

For example, when I began selling custom name signs, I didn’t just sell one version of the sign. I created multiple versions, each targeting a specific audience or occasion, which helped me stand out as the leader in that niche. When customers searched for custom name signs, my shop appeared first because of the variety and quality of my listings.

Step 3: Customization Is Key

When you’re thinking about what to sell on Etsy, look for products that can be customized to meet different customer needs. Customization allows you to take one product and create multiple variations, appealing to a wider audience without reinventing the wheel every time you make a sale.

For example, if you’re selling custom name signs, offer various customization options like size, color, font, and material. This gives your customers the flexibility to order something unique, and it makes your product stand out from others on Etsy.

Customization not only increases the perceived value of your product but also helps you generate more listings for the same core item. This is how you create multiple revenue streams from just one product. Take a look at this custom name sign as an example. The seller offers different colors, sizes, and designs, which allows them to target different types of buyers—all with the same product.

Step 4: Scale Through Multiple Listings of One Product

One of the best ways to scale a single item on Etsy is by creating multiple targeted listings for it. This is where many sellers miss an opportunity. They create one listing for a product and leave it at that. But to really drive sales, you should be creating numerous listings that target different customer needs.

For instance, if you’re selling a product like a custom name sign, you could create listings for:

• High school or college graduation gifts
• First birthday party decor
• Wedding reception signs

Each listing should have a different title and tags, optimized for the keywords your target customers are searching for. This way, when people look for what to sell on Etsy or for specific items like “baby shower decor” or “personalized wedding gifts,” your listings will show up in multiple relevant search results.

This is how I was able to turn one product into a revenue-generating machine. By creating multiple listings of the same item, each tailored to a unique buyer persona, I increased my shop’s visibility across Etsy.

Step 5: Optimize for SEO and Use Lifestyle Photos

When choosing what to sell on Etsy, SEO (Search Engine Optimization) plays a critical role in getting your products in front of customers. Each listing should be optimized with keywords that match what people are searching for on Etsy.

For example, a product like a custom t-shirt can have multiple listings, each targeting different search terms:

• “Personalized mom shirts”
• “Teacher appreciation gifts”
• “Father’s Day custom t-shirts”

By using lifestyle photos and well-researched keywords, your listings will perform better in Etsy search results. If you sell customizable products, make sure to take photos of each variation and use them to create new listings. This allows you to optimize for more search terms without constantly creating new products.

Step 6: Examples of the Best Products to Sell on Etsy

Here are two examples of what to sell on Etsy that can be scaled to over $500,000 in sales, following the strategies we’ve discussed:

1. Custom Name Signs
   Customization options for size, font, color, and design make name signs a highly versatile and sought-after product. You can create listings for different occasions like weddings, birthdays, or home decor. By targeting specific customer types and using SEO effectively, you can dominate this niche.
2. Personalized Apparel
   Personalized t-shirts and hoodies offer endless customization options, allowing you to target a wide range of customer groups. From moms and teachers to dads and couples, the possibilities are endless. By creating multiple listings for the same product with different keyword focuses, you can scale your personalized apparel shop quickly.

---

FAQs: What to Sell on Etsy

1. How do I choose what to sell on Etsy?
Start by focusing on one customizable product that appeals to a broad audience. This allows you to scale the product through multiple listings and become a market leader in that category.

2. Can I really make $500,000 with one item?
Yes! By choosing a highly customizable product and using targeted listings optimized for SEO, you can generate significant sales from a single product.

3. Why is customization important for Etsy products?
Customization adds value to your products and allows you to create variations that appeal to different customers, increasing your chances of making a sale.

---

Ready to learn more about growing an Etsy shop?

Book a call with us to discuss your Etsy shop, any struggles, and hear more about how we can help you through my program, Multi-Six Figure Etsy Blueprint and 1:1 coaching! https://calendly.com/dylanjahraus/program-strategy-call?month=2024-07

View our student Results: https://dylanjahraus.com/reviews